I started watching Avatar: The last airbender yesterday. I will do my best as an anime fanatic and expert in pugilistic Chinese mythos to not judge the Nickelodeon show in those aspects as it would be basically comparing apples and oranges, but instead focus on the character and story development that many of my friends have praised. But there will be some comparisons, and I will occasionally write out my thoughts of the show and a final review at the end (I will do my best to finish the show, but time constraints are in place this summer for other goals and responsibilities).
May 26th
The animation is decent, comparable to the beginning of Naruto and other American TV shows like Jackie Chan Adventures. Its not up to par with japanese animation studios, but that would be like comparing Bollywood with Hollywood. Japanese just have better technology, experience, and fan base to promote growth. But the animation is still pretty solid.
Character voicing is decent, though obviously the added childish gag humor that, as a 24 year old, I find tedious. Please lay off the puns and jokes and focus on growth and struggle and hope. That is something I like about japanese anime...there are less of those and usually take a more serious tone. But I guess a little bit of childishness is needed from time to time.
The flying bison reminds me of totoro. Now the animation style reminds me of pokemon's
May 31st
Almost done with book 1. Its not bad, though sometimes the childishness doesn't mix well with the seriousness. Its like one episode starts with silliness/goofiness, and then it all of the sudden transitions into a vicious battle. Also some parts where Aang basically kills enemies (dropping avalanches onto soldiers or blasting them off cliffs), but obviously the show doesn't reveal the casualties. That's what I liked about Eureka Seven. It showed what killing your enemies could do to a young kid with a lot of responsibility, and showed a whole arc with how the boy realized it, tried to run away from the responsibility, cope with it, and eventually finding another path. I would love to see Aang grow in a similar manner like this (I've read that it happens a little...but only a little).
I found it interesting that the water bender master would all of the sudden start training Katara after finding out she is the granddaughter of the one who broke your heart. Guess with age comes forgiveness and compassion (even if he acts like a prick, but I guess he has his strengths).
The episode by episode feel doesn't suit me, but I'll get used to it.
Ah the friendzone episode. Also the relationship between Sokka and Yume...its worse than Twilight. But he is quite the player. Edit: Scratch that. It is Bella, forgot the vampire's name (pssh Edward), and Jacob all over again.
I also found water bending, air bending, and even earth bending in the Jing Yong tv shows I watched as a kid. Interesting.
June 1st
Nostalgic effect. Just like how I like Gundam F91 and Gundam Wing, but recognize they aren't actually that good (almost to the point of terrible), I cannot stop liking them because they are part of my childhood. This is the same with avatar for many, especially people who watched it in high school or earlier (or those in college). It isn't actually bad, but its not the super show that people make it out to be. The characters aren't that unique or multi-faceted, but are actually kind of cliche.
I really like Appa and Momo a lot.
June 3rd
Someone pointed out how Avatar is really similar to Brandon Sanderson's Mistborn Trilogy. Very very similar.
You have the avatar. You have the hero of ages (who ends up being the person who is the monk, not the main character).
You have the good spirit and devil spirit in Avatar Korra, like you have Ruin and Preservation.
You have the 4 elements and bending, just like you have the different metals and alloys in allomancy (and in his other worlds, all in one universe).
You have the defeat of King Ozai, just like you have the defeat of the emperor, releasing even more powerful gods.
Even with the sequels, it shows how technology and advancement has to mix with the magic systems.
I honestly believe the makers of Avatar must have had some influence from Brandon Sanderson's stories. Or they are just plain geniuses of the same level of storytelling and magic-system crafting. The makers of Avatar have my respect.
June 5th
I really like the dancing episode of Avatar, and the bond between Momo and Appa. Man I love those two. You finally see some reality hitting Aang, and finally see some true growth. The fighting has improved, nothing flashy but very well done. It is semi-realistic, which I approve of, and the camera work is good. I started to notice the exact real stances that were put into the show for each element, as well as the swordfighting.
Still, one episode of Naruto (the latest one) completely dwarfs the feels and passion and realism and awesomeness of the entire show.
If only Avatar killed off some people. Seems to make the show have more meaning, and realism, and umph (not too much...GoT).
June 10th
Zuko's character is really...not very convincing. Also, fusion-ha...I mean...dragon dance.
June 15th
Finished the show a few days ago, but needed some time to marinate on my final review.
It was a strong and solid show. General animation only got better from beginning to end. The fighting animation and style stayed consistent throughout the show, and was simple yet attractive to the eye, loyal to traditional Chinese martial art movements (as much as I know). I actually enjoy it a lot better than most modern anime fighting animation, which tends to be unrealistic, overly dramatic, and too fast and flashy. I do not like flashy. I feel like that is a step in the wrong direction for the entire anime industry, and they can learn a thing or two from Avatar.
The music as enjoyable, cheesy at times, childish at times, and mostly not asian but more native american at times. Still, it complements the show well.
There were weaknesses. The characters were cookie cutter american cartoon. The praised character growth was overly hyped and didn't match my expectations. Even when people said the characters grew physically, I cannot say I noticed it. There were episodes where you see Aang confront his responsibility and destiny, and you see Katara grow from a useless girl into a formidable water bender, and Sokka only stayed annoying throughout the show and somehow managed to get cute girlfriends, but none of these were consistent, extraordinary, or believable. I am being too harsh, but it was waaaaaaaaay too overly hyped.
The ending of the show seemed very rushed, with all of Aang's lackluster training completely useless due to the
Deus ex machina return of Aang's avatar state. There wasn't too much large scale fighting at the end, and the whole blimp destruction seemed way too easy and cliche. The most puzzling plot point was the love story between Aang and Katara. Everything was resolved without an explanation in the last episode. No real DTR. No real transition or exploration of Katara's "I'm not sure" state.
Final thoughts. For this show to be considered worthwhile (by me), I must be able to relate, to grow, and gain from watching the show. I definitely enjoyed it. I may be a little too old to grow from it, and the characters were relatable. The limitations of the show as a children's cartoon were noticeable throughout, like filler episodes, lack of violence, and realistic adults, but it is what it is. I already harped on this, but people do get hurt in the show (despite Aang's remarks while on turtle island), and an exploration of this fact was missing from the show. Just like my maturity post, for there to be good character development in a story, there has to be struggles/hurdles and revelations of simple life truths. Compared to the other stories I was following during break, like Words of Radiance and Tigana, it definitely couldn't compare. The Avatar got nothing on The Radiants and shardblades, and doesn't have enough characterization, emotion, and hair-pulling decision making of one of fantasy's classics. Still it was the best American cartoon I've seen to date.
Above all else, I loved the animals in the show. "heart" Appa and Momo.